El Paso County Crime

Former EPSO Sheriff files notice of intent to sue for defamation

EL PASO COUNTY, Colo. - The former sheriff of El Paso County Terry Maketa has filed an intent to sue for defamation against several people, including current Sheriff Bill Elder. 

Dave Rose with El Paso County confirmed that attorneys are asking for payouts of up to $10 million each for Maketa, former Undersheriff Paula Presley and former Commander Juan "John" San Agustin.


Notices were served to more than 30 individuals, including current Sheriff Bill Elder, District Attorney Dan May, Colorado Attorney General Cynthia Coffman, and the top official in the Colorado Bureau of Investigation.

“This is not a lawsuit. This is nothing more than a letter threatening to sue members of this office," said Chief Deputy District Attorney Rich Orman, who handles lawsuit claims against the District Attorney’s Office for the 18th Judicial District. "We commonly receive letters from people threatening to sue us for the job we do as prosecutors."

Maketa, Presley, and San Agustin were indicted in May. Maketa is accused of having inappropriate relationships with three female subordinates, who he later promoted in the sheriff's office. 

Maketa and Presley are each charged with six felonies and San Agustin faces two felony counts.

The El Paso County refused to comment. 


Investigation into former sheriff Terry Maketa referred to 18th Judicial District

UPDATE: Former El Paso County sheriff makes first court appearance

Maketa surrenders in Gilpin County

Indictment papers reveal new details about allegations against Maketa


comments powered by Disqus

Must See Videos

  • WATCH Roller coaster road conditions in Colorado Springs Tuesday
  • Local snow removal crews Storm didnt catch us offguard
  • Lawmakers Consider Bills to Protect Colorado Schools
  • Report Hundreds sexually abused by USA Swimming coaches