Pueblo County Crime

Evidence found in day 2 of renewed Schelling investigation

10 p.m. update on Kelsie Schelling investigation

PUEBLO, Colo. - For a second day, investigators with the Pueblo Police Department and the Colorado Bureau of Investigation are searching a property where Kelsie Schelling's ex-boyfriend, Donthe Lucas, once lived. 

The home is located in the 5100 block of Manor Ridge Road on the south side of the city.

At around 4 p.m., police announced that they have found and bagged evidence.  They would not say specifically what they found.

The search, which includes digging up several areas in the backyard, began on Thursday. Police say they obtained a search warrant after receiving a new tip in Schelling's disappearance. 

Schelling was last seen at the Walmart in the 4000 block of W. Northern Avenue on February 4, 2013.

Police say Schelling, who is from Denver, went to the store to meet Donthe Lucas and tell him that she was pregnant. Donthe Lucas and tell him that she was pregnant. 

Several days later, police say that someone moved her car from Walmart and abandoned it at St. Mary-Corwin Hospital.

Police questioned Lucas after Schelling's disappearance. They have previously said that they do not have any evidence that he was involved. Lucas has denied having a relationship with Schelling.

ABC's news magazine show "20/20" featured Schelling's case last year. Her family hoped the nation-wide exposure would lead to a break in the case in the weeks that followed, but that didn't happen.

The "20/20" report featured tapes of police interviewing Lucas after Schelling's disappearance. During an initial interview with police, Lucas told detectives he went with Schelling to Parkview Medical Center in Pueblo because she wasn't feeling well. Lucas said she went in for two hours and then came out and told him she wasn't pregnant anymore.

However, the medical center had no record of Schelling ever stepping foot in the building. Additionally, surveillance video from a bank showed Lucas driving up alone in Schelling's car and withdrawing $400 in cash from her bank account.

Police brought Lucas in for a second interview. He was interviewed by detectives Neal Robinson and Gabe Maldonado. The detectives confront Lucas about the cash and no trace of Schelling at Parkview Medical Center.

comments powered by Disqus

Must See Videos

  • Stories of inspiration and strength from those at the 117Fire
  • Volunteers help ease frustrations for Hanover fire evacuees
  • Crews work to find and eliminate hot spots in Hanover
  • Memorial Central Hospital in Colorado Springs gets new status
  • Five homeowners return to destruction after Barnett Fire near Pueblo